extract with AA on CTG layer

[schwarzgrau]

I would like to set the default to "Extract with Anti-Aliasing" when extracting the color of a CTG layer. I always have to check it first and then open the window again to extract it.
Is there any downside using Anti Antialising or why isn't it checked by default?

extract.jpg (30.04 KiB) Viewed 32023 times

[neonnoodle]

I would like to set the default to "Extract with Anti-Aliasing" when extracting the color of a CTG layer.

Yes, I'd like this functionality by default also. It would be nice to be able to run the extraction command from a keyboard shortcut too.

[Elodie]

Sorry, but we were asked by many productions to not activate AA, as they need 100% opaque pixels for the post-production process.

[ZigOtto]

Sorry, but we were asked by many productions to not activate AA, as they need 100% opaque pixels for the post-production process.

why not to remember the last user's choice as default for the next tvpa session ?
with that, everybody will be happy, no AA for the ones who want exclusively full-opaque pixels,
and with AA for the ones who don't care the edging partially-transparent pixels coming with the AA mode.

[Elodie]

That makes more sense. > to do listed !

[schwarzgrau]

Good proposal zygote and thank you for listing it Elodie

[Paul Fierlinger]

zygote

[schwarzgrau]

I should stop posting here on my phone. Sorry ZigOtto.

[Elodie]

[ZigOtto]

Zig, Zygote, Zygomaticus, ... everything is fine !

[Elodie]

Looks like conjugation in Latin...

[schwarzgrau]

I don't know if it's possible, but maybe the anti-aliasing behavior could be set in the layer presets.

[schwarzgrau]

CTG Layers :

· An option to erase all of the existing colors and scribbles has been added in the Edit Color panel of the CTG Layer.
· Extract color now allows selected colors to be exported in the same layer or separately.
· Extract Color now remembers AA choice.
· Erase Scribbles now sorks with Right-Mouse Button (RMB).
· A Deactivate CTG after extraction option has been added in the Extract Colors popup.
· It's now possible to create a new palette from CTG layer's palette.
· The Edit colors panel of the CTG layer is now resizable and has a scrollbar.
· When using Load Structure from Sources, if the CTG Layer is inactive, the created instances will be empty, but the scribbles will be kept and applied when the CTG will be activated again.

Either I don't understand how it should work or it doesn't work for me. If I create a new CTG layer Anti-Aliasing is unchecked. I turn it on and extract the colors. On the next layer Anti-Aliasing is again unchecked by default. Is this the normal behaviour?

[NathanOtano]

Yes I agree that i would also like TVP to remember the AA settings for all past and new layers, don't think it's the case with the new version.

[Fabrice]

maybe a bug.